The Master Chef is a competition organised in some countries to choose the best 'chef' for the season. The candidates are chosen from a number of contestants whose skills are tested on basic skills as well as presentation, texture etc. I have had the misfortune to watch the latest 'Master Chef' Season from Australia presented over 'Star World'. This reality programme is watched by Asians daily with great interest, but some incidents and the attitude of many judges have given rise to the question as to whether these so called judges are really qualified to judge international cuisines.
The method chosen for presenting awards to a chef is questionable? The people presenting the series boast about the number of 'hats' different judges have won. I presume these 'hat's are awards given by some Organisation having a membership of chefs from around the world. Who decides these awards should be given? Where the Entertainment Industry is concerned, the general public vote for the person whom they think is the best. It is the ultimate consumer who decides who should be awarded. The one with the most number of votes is finally chosen. In my opinion, this should also be the way a chef is chosen for awards.
The chefs judging the competition must be qualified to speak about the cuisine that is cooked. The food is cooked by contestants coming from different nationalities. In this respect the so called 'judges' must be an expert in all the cuisines of the world. This is an impossible situation as no one can be an expert at International cuisines. In other words, a chef who is an expert at French cuisine can be considered qualified to judge French cuisine, but Japanese or Indian cuisines are not part of French culture. So it would be absolutely ridiculous and insulting if such a person tried to judge cuisines of other countries based on their idea of what is correct. A country's cuisine which includes the ingredients that provide flavour and texture, and the presentation of such food is an intrinsic part of its culture. A chef must respect and understand the culture. It would be an insult to the people of that country if these so called judges expected the contestants to present their food in the way 'they' consider appealing. It is bad enough the 5 star hotels are insulting our culture by toning down our food to such low standards to suit the tongues of Westerners used to eating boiled food with limited flavours. However, a competition organised to choose the best chef should NOT compromise on the culture. To illustrate: in the tests for the finals (that is to choose from 8) there were three judges who between them had fifteen hats. One of them was a female probably hailing from an ASEAN country. One of the contestants - Jimmy, an Indian presented a Lamb Pilau with Korma. The Asians watching the programme found his presentation a 'feast to the eyes' and mouth watering, but the 'judges' made some disgusting remarks about his food. According to them "the presentation was over whelming" and "there were too many layers". These statements display the paucity of knowledge of these judges in Moghul food and a lack of respect for Asian cusines. A "pilau" is a food served in mulitple layers consisting of rice, meat, fried potatoes, fried nuts and raisins and birista and repeated in the same order atleast twice. Only a racist who can't stomach asian food would call it over whelming. If the contestants had to change the presentation to suit their disgusting brains then it wont be asian but a bogus cuisine.
The Food presented as examples for cooking must be the proper food and not a dubious one. Let me elucidate by explaining what happened in another episode in the Australian Master Chef series. The contestants were given a Chicken Kurma (an Indian dish) to taste and were told to cook just like that. Firstly, the so called Kurma consisted of two ingredients namely saffron and paprika which are not used in a Kurma. These judges not only had the audacity to produce a dubious dish and call it the original but they even decided against a contestant who didn't use those two ingredients. Asians living in the sub continent found this shocking. In this scenario it is doubtful whether the chefs judging the competition are 'qualified'.
To conclude, I would say that to pass judgement on another's cooking one must be an expert in that type of cuisine. To do so otherwise, would be, to risk insulting others and reducing one's stock in the eyes of other people. As an Asian I wouldn't dare tell a Japanese how to cook their food as eating fish raw is part of their religious beliefs. The chefs chosen for judging in the Master Chef should do well to remember that they are not God and that they do not have the right to change other people's culture.
No comments:
Post a Comment